In Praise of the Grinch
By Jerry Griswold
There’s something about Christmas that can bring out the curmudgeon in us. For a person of unblinking honesty, the holiday season (as wonderful as it is) offers plenty of things to hate: department stores that begin decorating shortly after Halloween, those damnably cute red-and-white elf hats that some folks wear, the chore of Christmas cards. But say one critical word about the holiday and you’re immediately assaulted by coercive group-think, by the sanctimonious herd who’ll tell you: “Get in the spirit” and “Don’t be a Grinch.”
The crankiness sometimes evoked by Christmas seems a reaction to an excess of sentimentality and the pathetic that is common during the holiday season. Consider how the typical Christmas story is pathetically touching: Hans Christian Andersen’s Little Matchgirl freezing to death in the streets of an uncaring world while others celebrate indoors around their Christmas trees; the March sisters sacrificing their Christmas dinner to the poor German family in Little Women; the gifts of a hairbrush and watch chain to the shorn wife and watch-less husband in O’Henry’s “The Gift of the Magi.” If that isn’t enough of the touching, consider how many times during the season that the films “Miracle on 34th Street” and “It’s a Wonderful Life” will appear on television. And if that still isn’t enough, consider how many times newspapers will feature stories about someone who did a good deed and felt warm inside. In small doses this is fine; but after a certain point, all this seems too much and enough to make a diabetic wince.
This is Grinch territory, and we might begin to explore it by noting a curious post-holiday phenomenon of the last decade or so. After a long period of good behavior and kind feelings in the run-up to Christmas, and after plumping themselves with holiday dinners, folks have gone to movie theaters for the opposite, for mayhem and mischief, for a scary rather than a merry Christmas: “Gremlins” (where teddy-bear-like creatures become murderous in a shootout at, of all places, the Holy-of-Holies, a toy store); “Scrooged” (where in a reprise on Dickens’ story, Bill Murray plays an arrogant network exec assaulted by monsters that would make Darth Vader tremble); “The Grinch” (both the recent film with Jim Carrey and the popular animated version where Boris Karloff supplies the sinister creature’s voice); “Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas”; and more. Call these all examples of the “Dark Christmas” or “Christmas.alt.”
The first to do this was Charles Dickens’ in A Christmas Carol. While not completely free of sentimentality (think of the crippled Tiny Tim and his concluding the tale with “God bless us, every one”), Dickens’ story is a surprisingly dark holiday entry: a nightmare where ghosts go clanking about and Ebenezer Scrooge has a change of heart in a graveyard. Wait a minute! Where’s Rudolf the red-nosed reindeer and all his upbeat kin? Isn’t Christmas a time for happiness rather than remorse and scariness? Dickens’ classic seems to have mistakenly mixed up Christmas with Halloween.
Of course, Tim Burton mixes up these same dates in “The Nightmare Before Christmas,” his terrific upside-down version of Clement Moore’s famous holiday poem “The Night Before Christmas.” But the first upside-down version of Moore’s poem was Dr. Seuss’ How the Grinch Stole Christmas.
Indeed, anyone who has thoughtfully read the good doctor’s book will suddenly see Moore’s beloved holiday poem in a completely new way--as an account of greedy tots bent on “getting ” and poised in acquisitive anticipation:
Seuss provides the antidote to this picture of junior consumers with visions of sugar plums dancing in their heads; his parody even echoes Moore’s rhyme scheme. The Grinch (dressed as a sham St. Nick) and his dog Max (masquerading as a reindeer) travel to Who-ville and put Moore’s poem on “rewind.” Descending the chimney, the Grinch notices:
But this is only the beginning of his subtractions because the Grinch takes everything, from Christmas tree to yule log. But, you will remember, Christmas comes just the same:
And here is where the Grinch pauses: with the authentic, with the Xcess removed from Xmas. Properly understood, the Grinch is not the enemy of Christmas; he is the enemy of the inauthentic and insincere. At a time of year awash in over-the-top sentimentality and contrived touching stories, the hard-nosed Grinch wants to save Christmas from all the bogus frills and furbelows. He wants, in fact, to save us. As Tiny Tim might say, “God bless you, Dr. Seuss.”
..................................The Christmas Carol
Ages: 9 - 12The Night Before Christmas
By: Charles Dickens
Bantam: $3.95 (Paperback)
Ages: 4 - 8How the Grinch Stole Christmas!
By: Clement Moore; illustrated by Jan Brett
Putnam: $16.99 (Hardback)
Ages: 4 - 8Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas
By: Dr. Seuss
Random House: $14.00 (Hardback)
Touchstone Video: DVD and VHS ($14.99)
About the Author
Jerry Griswold is the Director of San Diego State University's National Center for the Study of Children's Literature. His most recent book is Feeling Like a Kid.
Copyright © 2009 Parents' Choice Foundation. All rights reserved.